The rustic texture, warm wood tones, and handcrafted appearance of cedar shake siding have a timeless quality that simultaneously makes a home feel comfortable and seaside. Many Florida homeowners who once loved the look of shake roofs are now choosing low-maintenance siding options that deliver the same classic style.. The problem is that natural wood is not particularly well-suited to Florida’s heat, humidity, and salt air. If cedar shake siding is not properly maintained, it may eventually fade, warp, or attract mold and insects.
For this reason, an increasing number of homeowners in Florida are inquiring about the best alternatives to cedar shake siding. We’ll learn about the alternatives to cedar shake siding in this article, along with their cost, advantages, and disadvantages, and why they make sense for homes in Florida.
Why Many Floridians Are Switching From Cedar Shake
Let’s start with the “why.” Cedar is undeniably attractive, but it may be difficult to manage in Florida’s environment. This is what causes homeowners to reconsider using real cedar siding:
Cost Over Time
Sometimes the initial beauty and charm are outweighed by the maintenance costs.
High Maintenance
Cedar roof maintenance requires regular staining or sealing to keep pests, dampness, and UV rays at bay.
Mold And Humidity
If Florida’s moist climate isn’t well ventilated, cedar may decay or develop mildew.
Pest Issues
Natural wood is a favorite of carpenter ants and termites.
You’re in luck if you love cedar roof’s beauty but dislike its maintenance.
Best Alternatives To Cedar Shake Siding
Let’s explore some of the most well-liked alternatives to cedar shake siding that Floridians are currently choosing.
Fiber Cement Siding
For homes in Florida, fiber cement is without a doubt the best alternative for cedar shake siding. Homeowners love it because it resembles real cedar but doesn’t rot, distort, or draw bugs. Even shake-style panels, which are more resistant to Florida’s humidity and salt air, are available from companies like James Hardie. These panels closely resemble the texture of real wood.
It works well for homes near the coast, in areas with high humidity, and for homeowners who desire the beauty of cedar without the trouble. For that genuine wood look and peace of mind during hurricane season, many Florida residents choose “HardieShingle®” or comparable fiber cement shake siding.
Vinyl Shake Siding
Vinyl shake siding is a good option if you want the traditional wood shake look but are on a tight budget. It is moisture-resistant, lightweight, and available in a variety of colors that don’t require repainting.
It is ideal for homeowners who desire a wood-inspired look without the upkeep or high cost of genuine cedar. In order to avoid warping or fading under Florida’s intense sun, look for UV-resistant vinyl siding made for hot climates.
Engineered Wood Siding
Another best alternatives to cedar shake siding is engineered wood siding, which provides the feel and appearance of natural wood with contemporary durability. It is constructed to withstand rot, moisture, and termites by combining wood fibers with resins and wax.
It is ideal for homeowners who enjoy the warmth of real wood but require additional defense against pests and moisture. One of the best engineered wood products, LP® SmartSide®, is renowned for its ability to withstand Florida’s climate without losing its genuine cedar grain.
Composite Shake Siding
Composite shake siding is something to think about if you want luxury with no maintenance. Composite siding, which is made of mixtures of recycled materials, polymers, or fiberglass, replicates the precise appearance of cedar shakes, down to the smallest details, without the susceptibility of genuine wood.
It works best for luxury homes or coastal residents who place a high value on long-term durability and aesthetics. In hurricane-prone places, composite shakes endure remarkably well—they do not swell, bend, or develop mold.
PVC Or Polymer Shake Siding
You are aware of how harsh salt air can be on external materials if you reside close to the water, such as in Jupiter, Palm Beach, or Naples. PVC or polymer shake siding excels in this situation.
For Florida’s coastal weather, these synthetic shakes are ideal substitutes for cedar shake siding because they are completely waterproof and resistant to rot.
Homes with beaches or those a few kilometers from the shore are the best candidates. PVC shake siding made especially for humid coastal areas like South Florida is available from companies like Tando and CertainTeed.
Metal Shake Siding
Although metal siding may sound industrial, metal shake siding is now a fashionable, energy-efficient, and surprisingly accurate cedar substitute thanks to advanced production techniques. Shakes made of steel and aluminum are coated and stamped to resemble wood grain, giving them a sleek, contemporary appeal.
It is ideal for homeowners who desire durability, energy efficiency, and a distinctive, high-end appearance.
Comparing The Best Alternatives To Cedar Shake Siding
| Siding Type | Cost (Installed) | Maintenance | Durability | Best For |
| Fiber Cement | $10–$14/sq. ft. | Low | 30–50 yrs | All Florida climates |
| Vinyl Shake | $6–$10/sq. ft. | Very Low | 20–30 yrs | Budget-friendly homes |
| Engineered Wood | $8–$13/sq. ft. | Moderate | 25–40 yrs | Classic wood look |
| Composite Shake | $12–$18/sq. ft. | Very Low | 40–50 yrs | Luxury properties |
| PVC/Polymer | $10–$16/sq. ft. | Very Low | 40+ yrs | Coastal areas |
| Metal Shake | $12–$20/sq. ft. | Very Low | 50+ yrs | Modern, hurricane zones |
Conclusion
When it comes to alternatives to cedar shake siding, Florida homeowners are spoiled for choice. There is an ideal choice for any budget and style, whether you’re looking for the easy maintenance of vinyl, the sleek durability of metal, or the rustic appearance of natural wood.
Fiber cement or engineered wood siding is a fantastic combination of durability and beauty if you reside inland or in a shady area. However, PVC, polymer, or composite siding will easily withstand humidity and salt air if your house is close to the shore.
The best part is that you can achieve the traditional cedar shake appeal with any of these substitutes without having to worry about decay, fading, or constant maintenance.
If you’re ready to upgrade your home’s exterior, contact Embick Roofing today for expert siding installation and professional advice on the best materials for Florida’s climate.
